Battle of Ideas Festival Audio Archive

The Battle of Ideas festival has been running since 2005, offering a space for high-level, thought-provoking public debate. The festival’s motto is FREE SPEECH ALLOWED. This archive is an opportunity to bring together recordings of debates from across the festival’s history, offering a wealth of ideas to enjoyed. The archive also acts as a historical record that will be invaluable in understanding both the issues and concerns of earlier years and the ways in which debates have evolved over time.

Listen on:

Episodes

6 hours ago

1 hr 36 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
Whichever way you look, the lanyard political classes are under siege. The spectacular rise of Reform UK in the polls – with soaring membership and increasing influence over policy discourse and media commentary – illustrates that nothing less than a political revolution is occurring. One shock to the system is that many believe that this insurgent party has replaced Labour as the party of the working class.
Some suggest this working-class characterisation is mythical. For example, one study by Queen Mary College found that Reform’s members are predominantly middle-aged, middle-class and aligned with values closer to the traditional Tory base than Labour’s working-class heartlands. But the truth is that Reform’s energy is derived from millions of ordinary voters – disillusioned with Conservative and Labour’s shift toward urban, lawyerly, technocratic governance, and furious their concerns have been contemptuously ignored or demonised. Reform’s anti-establishment, pro-sovereignty, anti ‘woke’ messages have cut through.
But is Reform the only game in town? Blue Labour, founded by Maurice Glasman in 2009, has emerged as a force. Lord Glasman has found himself somewhat a man of the moment after being the only Labour Party figure invited to Donald Trump’s inauguration. Moreover, JD Vance is rumoured to be a big fan, sending Glasman a copy of his Hillbilly Elegy in 2016 and personally issuing the invitation to the inauguration.
It is perhaps unsurprising, then, that No.10 is keen to bring Blue Labour ideas and philosophy on board – a move driven primarily by Starmer’s chief of staff, Morgan McSweeney. Moreover, the Blue Labour parliamentary caucus now has a double-digit number of MPs and seems to be growing. Given the widespread disillusionment with the Labour Party, many are asking if this family, faith and flag version of Labour can fill the soulless Starmerite shoes.
There may be some crossover in the cultural values that Reform and Blue Labour appeal to: the rejection of progressive agendas that have eroded British cultural identity, national pride, sovereignty, social obligation and civic order. But Blue Labour and Reform are very different in many ways, too. For example, Blue Labour sometimes argues that Reform is, at heart, a libertarian, Thatcherite party – pushing tax cuts, deregulation and privatised public services – that’s simply benefitting from a more general working-class fury.
Is it helpful to use traditional categories such as left and right, when this is – as characterised by Lord Glasman – a new era of sovereigntists versus globalists? Is Reform just a wrecking ball fuelled by the grievances of post-industrial areas, more a protest vote than a genuine working-class movement that can address structural economic issues? Do we know what we mean by the working class anyway? Can Blue Labour challenge existing left orthodoxy and save the Labour Party? Or are voters now seeking totally new institutions and a complete break from the old mainstream parties? And if Reform actually breaks the mould, will there be space for other challenger parties to flourish and make their mark?
SPEAKERSJonny Ballcontributing editor, UnHerd
Frank Furedisociologist and social commentator; executive director, MCC Brussels
Jonathan Hinder MPLabour MP for Pendle and Clitheroe
Scarlett Maguirefounder, Merlin Strategy
Gawain Towlerformer head of press, Reform UK
CHAIRClaire Foxdirector, Academy of Ideas; independent peer, House of Lords; author, I STILL Find That Offensive!

6 hours ago

1 hr 36 min

6 hours ago

1 hr 28 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
On 2 April, President Trump announced ‘Liberation Day’, imposing swingeing tariffs on imports, even on friendly countries with low or no trade surplus with the US. Using the tariffs, Trump has negotiated deals with a wide array of countries, with many on significantly favourable terms for the US. However, it is far from clear that the policy has solved America’s trade deficit and may indeed have made it worse. Many worry that the result may be higher prices for Americans.
The Western consensus for almost three-quarters of a century, following the end of the Second World War, was that the use of protectionism by developed countries was, at best, counter-productive for the imposing country and, at worst, a danger to global peace and prosperity.
Most economists from the centre and the right – and some from the left, too – criticised protectionist barriers to trade as being harmful to domestic economic prospects. They warned too that the imposition of protectionist measures by one country risked retaliatory escalations, which would spread adverse growth effects around the world.
However, attitudes to protectionism have moved rapidly in the past few years. It is not just that the tariffs imposed by the Trump administrations – and by Biden’s in between – have helped to normalise the use of protectionist measures. The increasing backlash during the 2010s to the iniquities of economic globalisation was already tarnishing the belief in the benefits of international trade. As a result, restrictions on trade seemed less sacrilegious.
Then the disruptions to global supply chains during the pandemic lockdowns, subsequently aggravated by the consequences of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, alerted Western leaders to their dependence on supplies from abroad. The wider rise of geopolitical tensions has further rekindled interest in protectionism as a means to promote domestic industries and reduce reliance on foreign producers.
Now protectionism is advocated as a legitimate means to advance a nation’s interests. So, were the downsides of protectionism always overstated? Can tariffs help an advanced country re-industrialise and become more self-sufficient? Doesn’t the reawakened legitimacy of national interest justify protectionism as bettering the lives of a country’s population?
SPEAKERSWilliam Cloustonparty leader, Social Democratic Party
William C. Hicksco-chair, Life Sciences Practice Group, Mintz
Catherine McBrideeconomist and trade specialist
Phil Mullanwriter, lecturer and business manager; author, Beyond Confrontation: globalists, nationalists and their discontents
CHAIRRob Lyonsscience and technology director, Academy of Ideas; convenor, AoI Economy Forum; author, Panic on a Plate

6 hours ago

1 hr 28 min

Lawless Britain?

6 hours ago

6 hours ago

1 hr 31 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
Mexico – a country where cartel violence claims tens of thousands of lives each year – recently warned its citizens about the risks of visiting Britain: ‘Robberies and physical assaults, mainly involving knives, have increased’, says the official advice. This may be hyperbole, but the widesprread impression is that UK lawlessness is growing.
In London’s Oxford Street, a purple line marked ‘Mind the Grab’ has been added to the pavement to warn pedestrians of the dangers of phone snatching, as research found that 88 per cent of Londoners are now worried about their phones being stolen in the city. Also in London, gonzo politician Robert Jenrick’s video confronting open fare-dodging on the Tube went viral and was widely lauded by paying passengers who expressed fury and frustration at TfL staff’s seeming indifference as young men forced their way through the barriers.
But are life and crime in the UK really so grim? An essay by Fraser Nelson in The Times challenged this image of a lawless, broken Britain, pointing to crime surveys and other data to conclude that ‘our streets have seldom, if ever, been safer’. Nelson argues that our view has been skewed by social media and opportunistic populist politicians, creating a narrative of Britain close to ‘societal collapse’. This means ‘we’re in danger of losing sight of the country we live in’. The essay was lauded by many, but others viewed it as Pollyanna-ish, middle-class denialism disconnected from working-class concerns.
One explanation for these different perceptions is that, regardless of the stats, there has been an erosion of civility and an increase in brazen antisocial behaviour, which have had a demoralising impact on many communities – from listening to music without headphones on public transport to an epidemic of fly-tipping and shameless shoplifters walking out with arms full of goods, in full view of security. No wonder the public feel lawlessness is on the rise. And inevitably, with debates raging about huge increases in immigration, the narrative of a migrant-driven crimewave is gaining traction.
What is to be done? Another Times commentator, Jenni Russell, has criticised official advice ‘not to intervene when we witness trouble: harassment, muggings, stealing, drownings, children being hit or if we overhear domestic assaults… Our role is to make a call or a video and walk away. It’s never our business.’ Russell commends those ‘mould-breakers… defying the social and official pressure to stand back’, citing new political campaign group Looking for Growth who started cleaning graffiti from London’s Tube trains.
How can we galvanise people’s energy and create a collective response to counter a fatalistic fear of crime and help restore a sense of mutual obligation that can counter lawlessness and incivility?
SPEAKERSNeil Davenportcultural critic; head of faculty of social sciences, JFS Sixth Form Centre
Amy Gallaghernurse; political commentator
Rory Geogheganfounder and CEO, SafetyScore; founder, The Public Safety Foundation; former police officer and special adviser
Fatima Gunningreporter, Gript Media
Luke Trylexecutive director, More in Common UK; writer and commentator; former political special advisor
CHAIRSally Millarddirector of finance; co-founder, AoI Parents Forum

6 hours ago

1 hr 31 min

6 hours ago

1 hr 32 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
 
Ever since we started making food products in factories, there have been concerns about the dangers of mass-produced food. Where previously there were anxieties about ‘junk’ food, the current fashion is to worry about ‘ultra-processed’ foods (UPFs), particularly since the success of TV doctor Chris Van Tulleken’s book, Ultra Processed People.
Van Tulleken admits that defining UPFs is ‘tricky’, adding: ‘There isn’t a single definition, but they generally contain ingredients not used in home cooking’ along with more fat, sugar and salt. A more widely used definition is from the NOVA system: ‘Ultra-processed foods are formulations of ingredients, mostly of exclusive industrial use, typically created by series of industrial techniques and processes (hence “ultra-processed”).’ UPFs are damned for being ‘highly palatable’ and ‘highly profitable’.
By this definition, UPFs are ubiquitous, with more than half of our calorie intakes coming from them. Some seem obvious, like snack foods and confectionery. Most people would see these are fun to eat but not especially nutritious. But using Van Tulleken’s definition, even a loaf of Hovis wholemeal counts as a UPF. A study published in August in Nature Medicine claims that even when two diets are compared that both meet national nutritional standards, the one with minimally processed foods produced more weight loss than one containing UPFs.
But many nutrition researchers are critical of the concept of UPF. There is little evidence, they say, that industrial processes and ingredients not used at home are themselves cause for concern. They argue that when more mainstream categorisation of food is applied – measuring things like calories, fat and fibre – the effect of UPF seems to disappear.
Should we avoid UPFs? How else might we explain the rise of obesity and chronic health conditions like diabetes? Is ‘highly palatable’ just a fancy way of saying ‘tasty’? Is there an element of snobbery about mass production and big, successful food companies?
SPEAKERSTonia Buxtonpresenter and executive producer, My Greek Kitchen; author; nutritionist
Suzanne Evansdirector, Political Insight
Timandra Harknessjournalist, writer and broadcaster; author, Technology is Not the Problem and Big Data: does size matter?; presenter, Radio 4's FutureProofing and How to Disagree
Milli Hillfreelance journalist; founder, Positive Birth Movement; author, Ultra-Processed Women
Christopher Snowdonhead of lifestyle economics, Institute of Economic Affairs; author, Killjoys and other books; co-host, Last Orders
CHAIRAlan Millerco-founder and chair, Together Association

6 hours ago

1 hr 32 min

6 hours ago

1 hr 29 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
The Middle East is again at the epicentre of the news – though it never really left. War rages in Gaza, unrest flares up in Lebanon, regime change has left Syria convulsing, and the long confrontation between Iran and Israel – which ignited this year – looms over it all.
Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia signs record-breaking arms deals, Yemen’s conflict smoulders away, and the Gulf States vie to position themselves as the technotopias of the future. Hovering above it all are the constant policy recalibrations of the US, China, Russia and the European powers, each manoeuvring for advantage.
The region is always described as home to ‘ancient rivalries’,  but what is really shaping the region today, and who will determine its future?
Some point to Israel’s grand attempt to cripple its enemies, from Hamas to Hezbollah and Iran, as the decisive factor. Others suggest that the conflict has left Israel isolated on the international stage. Or perhaps it will be the Gulf States who are decisive, their financial power transforming into diplomatic power, especially if the signatories to the Abraham Accords widen? Perhaps the rivalry between Saudia Arabia and Qatar will be the decisive factor in the region.
Other analysts insist on the importance of Turkey, attempting to cement its role as a regional hegemon. Some point to deeper trends – such as religious competition or a shift away from oil – that will determine the fate of the region. Or perhaps Trump – with his vision of endless trade and a ‘Gaza Riveria’ – will be the determining factor?
The Middle East has long been discussed only in relation to the ill-judged attempts of foreign powers to meddle in, change or dominate the region. Is it time to ask: who within the region will determine its fate?
SPEAKERSChris Baylisswriter and consultant
Dr Tim Blackbooks and essays editor, spiked
Nick Busvine OBEconsultant; founding partner, Herminius Holdings Ltd; advisory board member, Briefings for Britain; former diplomat, Foreign and Commonwealth Office
Anne-Elisabeth Moutetcolumnist and commentator for Telegraph, UnHerd, GB News, BFMTV (Paris)
Dr Ralph Schoellhammercommentator and podcaster; professor of International Relations; head of Center for Applied History and IR Theory, MCC Budapest
CHAIRJacob Reynoldshead of policy, MCC Brussels; associate fellow, Academy of Ideas

6 hours ago

1 hr 29 min

8 hours ago

1 hr 30 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
At what point does a low mood tip over into depression? When does a distressing experience qualify as trauma? When does a cluster of symptoms indicate an underlying condition? Are we really less psychologically healthy than previous generations? These are the questions asked by consultant neuropsychiatrist Dr Alastair Santhouse in his new book, No More Normal: Mental Health in an Age of Over-Diagnosis, and will be the focus of a discussion he will lead.  
As the conversation around mental health has moved from the consulting room to the public arena, so the concept of normal is shifting. Today, we are seeing an unprecedented rise in diagnosable conditions, in waiting lists, in diagnoses, and in medication.
The consequences of the new climate of diagnosis are immense. Overstretched mental-health services are not just a question of resources but rather a consequence of what some argue is a recent cultural trend: the problematic medicalisation of more and more aspects of the human condition. Ever-greater numbers of people are being encouraged – often by government-backed policies – to view normal, if adverse or perhaps painful, life events through the prism of mental illness.
As a consequence, a greater number of people now demand expert pharmacological or therapeutic intervention. The problems of worklessness and escalating sick leave, which the government are rightly tackling, seem dominated by those who have removed themselves from productive work because of mental health-related problems.
What’s more, over recent decades, this huge increase in classification in the psychological realm has moved the job of diagnosis far beyond the field of psychiatry. A veritable industry of counsellors, therapists and psychotherapeutic practitioners now label an ever-expanding set of behaviours as mental ill-health. Perhaps inevitably, as the number of labelled conditions has grown, those reporting that they suffer from such problems has risen exponentially as well.
Some worry that one unintended consequence of this pathologising of ever more aspects of life is that the system is becoming overwhelmed by inappropriate referrals and arguably over diagnosed conditions. Do we risk reducing the time and resources available to those who desperately need professional help?
What is to be done? Dr Santhouse proposes one solution: that we pull back from this diagnostic expansion, focus on the effective treatment of a core group of severe mental-health problems, and de-medicalise a vast range of other normal human experiences. But others worry this will neglect many who are so distressed and depressed that they feel they are in need a diagnosis and treatment, regardless of objective clinical factors?
SPEAKERSDr Ken McLaughlinformer social worker; academic; author, Surviving Identity: Vulnerability and the psychology of recognition and Stigma, and its discontents
Stella O'Malleypsychotherapist; director, Genspect; author, What Your Teen is Trying to Tell You
Alastair Santhouseconsultant neuropsychiatrist; author, No More Normal: Mental Health in an Age Over-Diagnosis
CHAIRKevin Rooneyreligion, philosophy and ethics teacher; editor, irishborderpoll.com; convenor, AoI Education Forum; co-author, The Blood Stained Poppy

8 hours ago

1 hr 30 min

8 hours ago

1 hr 24 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
Snitch, rat, squealer, tout, telltale, betrayer – breaching someone’s privacy used to be an immoral act. But in an era of WhatsApp groups, screenshots and the potential for things to go ‘viral’, keeping prying eyes at bay has become an impossible task. Snitching is no longer seen as a breach of trust. Instead, it is often given the honourable description of ‘whistleblowing’.
In the past, snitching would have to be done with a hidden tape recorder or a glass to a wall. But smartphones have enabled countless kinds of private conversations to be made public – often with serious ramifications. Parents have been visited by the police for criticising their children’s school on what they thought was a private parents’ WhatsApp group, and university students have been excommunicated for making tasteless jokes within what they thought were private chats. Social media sites like X are awash with eavesdroppers and snitches reporting on private conversations between people on buses, in pubs, in campus bars. Even former prime minister Boris Johnson’s private arguments with his wife made it to national news thanks to eavesdropping neighbours.
Some fear this snitch culture mirrors and fuels a broader societal mistrust of other people. We are all encouraged to be so hypersensitive to others’ offensive or harmful comments or banter that we will betray confidences to the authorities with the click of screenshot. Why do people now feel so little loyalty to each other that they share private communications?
Sometimes the line between public and private can feel hard to maintain when it comes to issues of wider importance. When someone leaked the private ‘rape chat’ amongst her male course mates to a female student at Warwick University, many believed it was right to expose such misogynist attitudes that led to expulsions and suspensions. When police officers made vile comments about victims on private WhatsApp groups, was this simply letting off steam among colleagues, or expressing behaviour that should be of public concern? Should Isabel Oakeshott have leaked Matt Hancock’s WhatsApp messages to the press, or should she have respected his privacy?
Then there is the morality of friends or colleagues happy to cut and paste messages and make them public, sometimes weaponising whistleblowing as malicious acts of public bullying. More broadly, what are the consequences if academics, politicians, heads of companies and even families are denied the space to make mistakes, thrash out ideas and think aloud, fearful that their words may be posted online, even reported to the police?
Where should we draw the line between what’s said in private and what matters for public attention? In a world where people’s intimate lives and thoughts can be shared worldwide at the touch of a button, is it possible to maintain these two lives – private and public – anymore? How can we encourage the young to trust each other if snitch culture is normalised?
SPEAKERSSabrina Esseschief privacy officer & data protection officer, UK and EU, Marsh McLennan
Stani Huepflresearcher, Stiftung Maximilianeum
Rosie Kaydancer; choreographer; CEO and artistic director, K2CO LTD; co-founder, Freedom in the Arts
Fraser Myersdeputy editor, spiked; host, the spiked podcast
Connie Shawexternal affairs officer, The Free Speech Union; contributor, GB News
CHAIRDr Tiffany Jenkinswriter and broadcaster; author, Strangers and Intimates and Keeping Their Marbles

8 hours ago

1 hr 24 min

9 hours ago

1 hr 32 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
AI continues its seemingly unstoppable encroachment into every aspect of life, throwing up major philosophical questions. Whether you’re into music, fine art or writing, employed as a programmer or journalist, or expected to provide critical insights and judgments – like a doctor with a patient – AI has become impossible to ignore.
Large Language Models (LLMs), like ChatGPT, can draw upon terabytes of human knowledge – already scanned, sorted and indexed – producing answers, artefacts and outputs in seconds, far beyond the capability of any individual human mind.
And yet, the central question is whether any of these outputs are in any sense human. Does it matter if something is partially or entirely created without human input? As humans, veracity and authenticity matter to us. Many insist that, however sophisticated these models get, they are only ever highly sophisticated prediction engines. They offer up answers with impressive confidence, but never perfect accuracy, and are always reliant on the user’s prompting. No AI is actually sentient, autonomous or able to imagine or genuinely reason.
Some argue that this distinction does not matter to the untrained eye. Is ‘good enough’ now… good enough? Do we care if an AI produces a passable pop song all by itself or generates an entire film from a single prompt? AI can offer a reasonably accurate prediction, after sifting through mountains of data, that otherwise might take a clinician months. AI can access seemingly unlimited knowledge, prototypes and stimulus, at little cost or effort. Aren’t these, on balance, good things?
But as singer and songwriter Nick Cave has argued, what makes something relatable, authentic and trustworthy is when we know it’s the result of someone’s intellectual and creative struggle. ‘Songs arise out of suffering, by which I mean they are predicated upon the complex, internal human struggle of creation and, well, as far as I know, algorithms don’t feel.’
Every technological advance seems to have prompted concerns about the blurring line between man and machine. Perhaps we should think of AI like the advent of the printing press, which expanded access to knowledge beyond the domain of the few. Or is the interaction with LLMs, and their staccato output, robbing us of what’s essentially human: being in a dialogue with messy, unpredictable others? For all the worries about whether AIs can be human, perhaps the real worry, with the explosion in AI-written essays and artworks, is that humans are becoming a little more like AI?
SPEAKERSDr JJ Charlesworthart critic; editor, ArtReview
Simon Cullenfaculty research fellow; visiting research professor of civil discourse and artificial intelligence, Heterodox Academy
Maeve Halliganco-founder and president, Cambridge University Society of Women; postgraduate student, Eastern European literature; Living Freedom alumna
Lauren Razaviexecutive director, Plumia; author, Global Natives
Dr Lola Salemlecturer in French and music, University of Oxford; author; professional singer, Maîtrise de Radio France
CHAIRMartyn Perksco-author, Big Potatoes: the London manifesto for innovation; former Islington by-election independent candidate; property investment broker

9 hours ago

1 hr 32 min

9 hours ago

1 hr 37 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
 
In April this year, the Supreme Court ruled that, in relation to references in equalities law, ‘women’ are biological females – putting an end to the claims that ‘trans women are women’. Or has it? Despite this significant legal victory for campaign group For Women Scotland and many others arguing for women’s rights, claims that the sex and gender wars are over might be premature.
On the one hand, much of the dominance of trans activism in the public realm seems to have been challenged. The Tavistock Clinic has been closed due to concerns about the number of children being referred for gender-reassignment treatment. Institutions like the BBC and the NHS dropped their Stonewall affiliation. Many politicians, who previously choked when asked what a woman is, now happily defer to the Supreme Court ruling and agree that women’s spaces should be for women only.
On the other hand, the ruling has not convinced everyone. Ofcom made the headlines in June, telling GB News that it still had to provide ‘balance’ by airing the view that trans women are women when discussing sex and gender. Petitions and boycotts have circulated to call for the government to row back on its support for the Supreme Court ruling. The trans poet Kate Tempest told a crowd at Glastonbury ‘they can shake their heads in despair but we’ve been here from the start, we ain’t going nowhere’. For many trans activists, the Supreme Court ruling was not a clarification of fact, but a declaration of war on their sense of identity.
The view that ‘trans women are women’ might be the view of a minority – one with shrinking policy and political support thanks to the Court ruling. But does that mean that the gender wars are over? Many argue that views on trans and women’s rights often take a generational split. How can we talk to young people about sex and gender when so often a pro-trans view is seen as the ‘right thing to do’? And where are the new battlegrounds in this war? Should we really believe that a cultural elite, who seemed so enthralled to trans ideology, is going to give way so easily?
SPEAKERSMarion Calderco-director, For Women Scotland
Tracy Edwardsround-the-world sailor; founder/trustee of the Maiden Factor Foundation
Simon Fanshaweconsultant and non-executive director, Diversity by Design
Michael Foranassociate professor of law, University of Oxford; tutorial fellow in law, Keble College, Oxford
Sonia Sodhacolumnist and broadcaster
CHAIRAlastair Donaldco-convenor, Battle of Ideas festival; convenor, Living Freedom; organiser, European Free Speech Network

9 hours ago

1 hr 37 min

9 hours ago

1 hr 34 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTIONIn his recent book, The End of Woke, writer Andrew Doyle notes that after years of an ‘intolerable, intemperate and above all illiberal’ cultural revolution, ‘woke ideology is being tamed and will soon relinquish its chokehold on the Western world’. That chokehold often seems to have been enforced through the programmes devised by a diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) industry – backed up by administrative and legal mechanisms to oversee recruitment, admissions and training that have proliferated across universities, institutions, the state and corporate sectors.
Now, the last rites for DEI are being hastily performed. In the US, an important Supreme Court ruling struck down racial preferences in university admissions. President Trump has declared DEI to be ‘dangerous, demeaning, and immoral’. The implications are rippling through institutions, public and private. Right-leaning activists such as Chris Rufo celebrate ‘the welcome death of DEI’. Even liberal publications like The Atlantic concede this is ‘the end of the DEI era’. In the UK, too, DEI is said to be sputtering, sometimes hoist by its own petard after embracing schemes such as Stonewall’s discredited Diversity Champions.
Yet it’s hard to discern definitively when societal trends end and new ones begin. On a practical level, regulators such as the Financial Conduct Authority and companies such as Amazon, McDonald’s, Lloyds Bank and BT say they will ditch diversity and inclusion rules. Yet in the UK, just 11 per cent of British firms surveyed say they plan similar changes, despite the existence of more than twice as many DEI officials deployed per head of population as any other country in the world. Others warn DEI is not being disbanded but rebranded, encouraged by campaigns such as ‘DEI by Stealth’.
Politically, the future is even more murky. While some saw the success of DEI as the result of an activist march through institutions, others say it reflects a more widespread cultural transformation. Certainly, political commitment to the DEI orthodoxies seems to run deep, with NHS, civil service and judicial bodies regularly recommitting to DEI principles.
Some charities and public bodies have expressed defiance of the UK Supreme Court ruling that ‘sex’ means biological reality. Universities such as Cambridge are expanding rather than contracting affirmative selection schemes. Reform UK, which took control of 10 councils in this year’s May local elections, report ‘obstructionism’ and CEOs ‘wilfully defying’ actions to dismantle DEI. Will opponents need to revoke regulatory and legislative underpinnings, such as the Public Sector Equality Duty, to finally kill the beast?
For others, the key challenge is to make DEI more workable. Luke Tryl of More in Common warns that whatever the excesses, changes driven by progressive activists are ranked high on the list of things the British people say they’re proudest of: advances in women’s rights and gay rights, reductions in outright racism. There’s a danger, he says, ‘that the pendulum will swing too far the other way and get rid of a whole load of stuff that the public actually supports’. Simon Fanshawe of Diversity by Design argues the practical solution is to ‘engage the entire workforce in DEI… and ensure DEI tactics are collaborative, not imposed’.
Is this the end of the road for the ‘lanyard class’? Ultimately, should DEI be saved or buried?
SPEAKERSDr Tim Crowleylecturer, School of Philosophy, University College Dublin; convenor, Dublin Academics for Academic Freedom
Andrew Doylewriter and comedian; author, The End of Woke: How the Culture War Went Too Far and What to Expect from the Counter-Revolution and The New Puritans
James Essespsychotherapist; writer and investigative journalist; founder, Just Therapy
Meghan Murphywriter and journalist; podcast host, The Same Drugs
Akua Reindorf KCbarrister, Cloisters Chambers
CHAIRElla Whelanco-convenor, Battle of Ideas festival; journalist; author, What Women Want

9 hours ago

1 hr 34 min

10 hours ago

48 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
 
When the Colston statue in Bristol was replaced with a sculpture of a fat, bald man wedged in a wheelie bin, there was little doubt it was meant as a slur against the white working class. The slogan ‘St George was Turkish’ was emblazoned on the side, just to make sure.  From Kent Police’s concerns about someone possessing ‘Brexity things’ to Newsnight’s ‘Wall of Gammon’ meme, taking aim at the working class seems to have become fair game.
Perhaps most surprisingly, these sorts of attacks appear to be coming from, or inspired by, the ‘progressive’ left. But does this contemporary notion of ‘progressive’ really amount to progress?
The idea of progress emerged in the Age of Enlightenment and was based on the belief that society can be improved through political reform. Historically, the concept has been associated with the political left, with a focus on reducing inequality and advocating for disadvantaged groups in society – specifically the working class.
However, in recent years, some critics have argued that the contemporary left has become dominated by an educated, urban elite who are more likely to subscribe to identity politics and support for globalisation policies such as those surrounding climate change and open borders. For such critics, this has created a gulf between progressives and the traditional working class – particularly over issues such as patriotism, family and faith.
In his new book, The Progress Trap: The Modern Left and the False Authority of History, Ben Cobley argues that the progressive belief about being ‘on the right side of history’ creates a form of moral authority that confers the right to act and control others.
Is Cobley right? Have today’s left-wing progressives become so detached from the working class they actually ‘despise’ them?  Or is it simply that the left have incorporated more groups – such as ethnic minorities – into the ‘disadvantaged group’ category?  Has the progressive turn towards identitarian politics and social justice alienated the working class, or is the trope of the ‘metropolitan liberal elite’ much overstated?
SPEAKERSBen Cobleyauthor, The Tribe: the liberal-left and the system of diversity and The Progress Trap; former Labour Party activist
Lisa McKenzieworking-class academic; author, Lockdown Diaries of the Working Class
David Skeltonauthor, The New Snobbery and Little Platoons
CHAIRHilary SaltGreater Manchester co-ordinator SDP; actuary; founder, First Actuarial

10 hours ago

48 min

10 hours ago

52 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
Feeding children can be a gruelling task. On top of the mess, the refusals and the sweating over the cooker, parents now have to contend with a new section of food commentary geared towards infants and toddlers. While some herald a new dawn of information about infant feeding, others have argued that science has taken precedence over the very basic common-sense aspect of parenting: what to make for dinner.
Read any report on how babies are fed in the early months of life, and you will soon come across references to the UK’s ‘dismal’ and ‘troubling’ low breastfeeding rate. ‘Breast is best’ is not only promoted by the NHS and the government, but also written into law via restrictions on how formula can be marketed. Such is the preference for breastfeeding, many food banks are still not allowed to provide infant formula to needy families.
Moreover, supporters of breastfeeding suggest that formula is an ‘ultra-processed food’ that is both bad for people and the environment. They point to previous scandals in developing nations around the marketing and use of formula milk and argue that breastfeeding is vital for nutrition and bonding between mother and baby. Furthermore, they suggest that many women stop breastfeeding before they would like to, because of remaining stigma around public feeding of babies.
Do they have a point? A recent documentary found that packets of baby food marketed as ‘healthy’ were overstating their claims, with few nutrients left after the packaging process. The term ‘ultra-processed babies’ has started knocking about, with scrutiny over toddler snacks like crisps and wafers. Baby-led weaning – the idea of giving babies their own food to eat instead of puree – is now promoted as the only right way to introduce solids by the NHS. There seems to be new rules popping up every day as to how and what you should feed your child.
For some, how to feed a baby is  a practical, simple question. For others, it raises wider issues about motherhood and women’s autonomy. Should we care which way babies are fed, as long as they are fed? Are we too hung up on the idea of ‘ultra processed’ when what most parents need is speed and ease? Are the advantages of breastfeeding really as overwhelming as many advocates suggest? Is the focus on children’s eating habits a positive move or are we in danger of raising a nation of fussy eaters with paranoid parents?
SPEAKERSMilli Hillfreelance journalist; founder, Positive Birth Movement; author, Ultra-Processed Women
Dr Renée HoenderkampGP; broadcaster; author
Catherine Roymaternity safety campaigner, Infant Feeding Alliance
Dr Rebecca Steinfeldreproductive rights researcher; special projects lead, campaigns and communications team, British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS)
CHAIRElla Whelanco-convenor, Battle of Ideas festival; journalist; author, What Women Want

10 hours ago

52 min

10 hours ago

43 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
 
Contempt of court has traditionally been respected as crucial to justice and fair trials. Even the most ardent free-speech absolutists respect not speaking out if comments might prejudice legal proceedings in criminal cases or not publishing information that could unfairly influence a trial. But over the past year or so, contempt of court rules have become the centre of some heated public controversies over political and media censorship, while their usefulness is queried in a social-media era.
For example, last summer, the public were told that court laws prevented the police, politicians and the media from revealing details about Axel Rudakubana, the man later charged with the brutal murders of three young girls in Stockport. In light of public uproar, this has now been addressed via interim guidance from the National Police Chiefs’ Council (NPCC). But a trend for withholding information about suspects – whether ethnicity or details of charges – in order to prevent a prejudiced jury, has seen the police and politicians accused of trying to contain political disquiet rather than ensure a fair trial.
In May last year, the New Yorker published a 13,000-word article by Rachel Aviv, which questioned the safety of the conviction of Lucy Letby. Cheshire Constabulary reported the article to the Attorney General’s Office suspecting it breached the Contempt of Court Act. Penalties for breaching this can include unlimited fines, trial collapse and imprisonment of editors or journalists. The piece was then ‘geoblocked’ and not available to people in the UK, on the basis it could influence jurors in Letby’s retrial, despite the anomaly of the article’s availability in print.
On both occasions, these laws led to an information vacuum in which misinformation, counternarratives and claims of cover ups could spread unchecked. In the case of Stockport, this at least contributed in part to a period of widespread civil unrest.
Fast forward to 2025 and other widely covered cases – such as the shooting of Chris Kaba and the assaults on police at Manchester Airport – have brought contempt of court laws into question. These can also include ignoring a court order, as in the case of Tommy Robinson, who was jailed for 18 months after admitting 10 breaches of a High Court injunction that barred him from repeating false allegations.
Some argue the law is outdated, as global online access undermines restrictions. During Letby’s original trial and retrial, online forums, social media and blogs extensively discussed the case, often breaching legal restrictions. Despite the law, Robinson’s film, Silenced, was shared to tens of millions globally via online platforms.
What is contempt of court and why does it exist? With the Law Commission currently reviewing the rules to improve their ‘effectiveness, consistency and coherence’, what will they be looking at? Should free speech be a consideration? How far should and could the Law Commission go? With even the staunchest defenders of the 1981 Act conceding that it has not kept pace with the digital world, is it finally time for a reboot?
SPEAKERSHelen Dalesenior writer, Law & Liberty; author, Kingdom of the Wicked
Jon Holbrookbarrister; writer, spiked, Critic, Conservative Woman
Professor Gavin Phillipsonprofessor of law, University of Bristol
CHAIRMax Sandersonassistant managing editor, Guardian

10 hours ago

43 min

10 hours ago

47 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
In The End of Woke, renowned writer and comedian Andrew Doyle traces the rise and fall of the ‘woke’ cultural revolution. Despite the progressives’ language of inclusivity, their approach to political change seems intolerant and illiberal. And if liberalism can be accused of underestimating, if not spawning, woke, the struggle against woke has bred an illiberalism of its own.
Woke politics now appears to have escaped the preexisting ideological confines of the left and right, as both sides have been captured by a cultural revolution that prioritises identity over the individual, and which doubles down on inequity caused by identitarian differentiation. This has seen the emergence of a ‘woke right’ as a mirror image of ‘social justice’ identitarians. Doyle pushes back against such political tribalism, which has fed into the current authoritarian political climate. The End of Woke envisions a civilised society built through tolerance and discussion, not a polarising climate uncapable of debate.
Doyle argues that despite the fading of woke movements, seen in the scaling back of diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) policies and the surge of support for Reform in the UK, the fight for liberalism remains. Woke gave power to institutional overreach, as organisations and a new elite have been given the power and the legal framework to shape speech and behaviour, under the guise of reducing weakly defined harm.
Some hope that with Trump’s return to the White House and an increasing loss of faith in the performative politics of the Labour government, real politics might be on the brink of a comeback. Or are we stuck in a cycle of extremes and mutually reinforcing grievances on all sides? With conformism masquerading as radicalism, can there be any hope of generating genuine social change and political movement? Can we make anew the case for tolerance and freedom in the twenty-first century? Is it too optimistic to declare the end of woke, or are we indeed at the beginning of the end of a poisonous ideology?
SPEAKERAndrew Doylewriter and comedian; author, The End of Woke: How the Culture War Went Too Far and What to Expect from the Counter-Revolution and The New Puritans
CHAIRToby Marshallfilm studies teacher; member, AoI Education Forum
 

10 hours ago

47 min

11 hours ago

1 hr 31 min

Recorded at the Battle of Ideas festival 2025 on Sunday 19 October at Church House, Westminster.
ORIGINAL INTRODUCTION
Prior to MPs approving the Assisted Dying Bill, concerns were raised about the way proposed legislation on such an important matter was introduced into parliament, by means of a private members’ bill. Further claims were levied at the use of a swath of technical procedures to increase the likelihood of the Bill being passed. Many argued that the committee was stacked with a majority of supportive MPs and heard a disproportionate amount of ‘expert’ testimony from those in favour of the Bill. MPs were left with little time for proper debate, especially in relation to last-minute amendments.
The whole process has led to widespread claims that the Bill was badly thought-through and insufficiently scrutinised. And yet this law – if passed – will fundamentally change the relationship between the state and individuals, and between the NHS and patients.
This is not the first time concerns have been raised about the erosion of parliamentary scrutiny and democratic debate. For example, in 2023, the then Conservative government’s Illegal Migration Act was said to have been subject to limited consultation and fast-tracked through parliament without proper debate. In June this year, an amendment was attached to the Crime and Policing Bill that stopped women being prosecuted in England and Wales for terminating their pregnancy at any stage, even up to birth. There was a backlash that another huge shift in legislation and societal norms took place without public debate.
Moreover, in July, Keir Starmer was forced to abandon core elements of the Welfare Bill, following a strong rebellion from Labour MPs and claims that the Bill had gone through so many changes it barely resembled the original. This led to a huge dint in the PM’s authority and – some say – the cause of Rachel Reeves’s emotional display at PMQs.
Wherever you stand on these issues, they represent big changes to UK law and to broader society. In each case, the legislative process has taken place with questions over proper democratic engagement. What’s more, where once the bypassing of proper parliamentary oversight was reserved for more technical matters for the sake of expediency, it seems clear that this has now been expanded into a wide range of more fundamental policy areas. The sheer number of laws using statutory instruments and Henry VIII powers, which defer detailed decisions to the executive and civil servants, seems to suggest an increased tendency to bypass both parliamentary and public accountability.
Using the example of the Assisted Dying Bill, this session will explore whether there are legitimate concerns surrounding the law-making process and whether it represents a threat to parliamentary sovereignty, the rule of law and to democracy itself. Do these trends illustrate a disdain for both elected politicians and the demos’s ability to determine the affairs of the nation?
SPEAKERSHannah Barnesassociate editor and writer, The New Statesman
Simon Calvertdeputy director, The Christian Institute
Lord MoylanConservative peer; opposition front bench spokesman on transport, House of Lords
Rajiv Shahformer special adviser
CHAIRProfessor Kevin Yuillemeritus professor of history, University of Sunderland; author, Assisted Suicide: the liberal, humanist case against legalization
 

11 hours ago

1 hr 31 min

Battle of Ideas festival archive

This project brings together audio recordings of the Battle of Ideas festival, organised by the Academy of Ideas, which has been running since 2005. We aim to publish thousands of recordings of debates on an enormous range of issues, producing a unique of political debate in the UK in the twenty-first century.

Copyright 2023 All rights reserved.

Podcast Powered By Podbean

Version: 20241125